patching...
Update: Subscribe to Long Beach Patch’s newsletter for daily, weekly and breaking news. »
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!

Long Beach City Council Declares Fiscal Emergency

Auditor reports on city's budgetary woes while some call for criminal investigation into prior administration.

 


Calls for a criminal investigation into the prior administration’s financial reports surrounded the Long Beach City Council’s unanimous vote to pass a resolution officially declaring a fiscal emergency at Tuesday’s meeting at City Hall.

An independent auditor, Scott Oling, a partner at the accounting firm O'Connor Davies Munns & Dobbins that was hired by the prior Republican administration, first briefed the council on the fiscal budget ending on June 30, 2011, in which he highlighted overspending in various departments, primarily the police and fire departments, and underfunding in the water fund and sewer fund, among others. Along with subsequent borrowing, Oling said, these practices contributed to depletion in the reserve fund from $7.4 million in 2008 to $107,000 on June 30, 2011.

“As it stands here, in June 2011, when you take that $2.2 million in total fund balance for the general fund and you set aside $1.1 million to cover the deficits in water and sewer, and $932,000 that was used to balance the current budget that you’re in, that gives you a total fund balance of only $107,000,” Oling explained.

The auditor's report also confirmed that, as of last June, the city owes $48 million in general obligation debt, and Oling projected that, come June 2012, “most likely the general fund will be in a deficit along with the water and sewer funds.”

City Manager Jack Schnirman indicated that it remains too early to say exactly what measures the city will adopt to correct the city’s budgetary woes, among which are possible layoffs, increased taxes, reduced services and spending cuts. “We’re not going to have a corrective action plan immediately,” Schnirman said, adding that other actions must be taken first.  

On Dec. 20, Moody’s Investor Services downgraded the city’s A1 bond rating to Baa3, and the ratings agency will reevaluate the city’s financial standing in 90 to 120 days from that date. Schnirman said Moody’s has put Long Beach on a negative watch list during this time, and if the city fails to take substantive steps toward stabilizing its finances, the agency could further downgrade the city’s credit rating.

“We want to make it extremely clear to all of us here that the city misrepresented its financial numbers and information,” said Schnirman, echoing what he said was Moody’s assessment of the previous administration’s financial reports.

Moody’s stated that the most recent information the prior administration gave to them, Schnirman continued, “was extremely different than the information they were given beforehand, and they felt that the city had misrepresented its financial information.”

Councilman Scott Mandel, as well as some residents, asked whether a criminal investigation into the prior administration’s financial practices might be initiated. Corey Klein, the city’s attorney, said that with the direction of the city manager, the city could present the relevant information to the Nassau County District Attorneys Office and even the FBI and ask that they consider an investigation. 

Neither former Council President Thomas Sofield Jr., nor former City Manager Charles Theofan attended Tuesday’s meeting. Theofan had reportedly defended his administration’s financial management and said the impact of the national recession was finally catching up to Long Beach

Moody’s downgrade came after the city announced a cash-flow shortfall in November, when former City Comptroller Sandra Clarson notified Theofan that the city faced a $1.3 million deficit at the end of 2011, threatening the year-end payroll. At Clarson’s recommendation the City Council approved a proposal to borrow $4.5 million, in part to cover a payroll shortfall in December and to payout contractual obligation for retirees, using anticipation and budget notes.

The new Democrat-majority City Council tabled the resolution to declare a fiscal emergency at the Jan. 17 meeting, in part to await the auditor’s report that was released Monday, and in order to clarify language that gives the city manager more authority to control and veto spending items, including items in the current budget. Schnirman pointed out that the rewritten resolution calls for the City Council to approve measures he proposes and that this expansion of authority will terminate on June 30, 2012. 

The next City Council meeting is on Feb. 21.

Related Topics: Long Beach City of Long Beach and Long Beach Patch

Jimmy Hennessy

9:33 am on Wednesday, February 8, 2012

Only in Long Beach can a $107,000 fund balance (surplus) be considered a "fiscal crisis!"

Read the above carefully. The independent auditor reports that at the end of the budget year, there was a $107,000 remaining as a fund balance, otherwise known as a surplus, but the current administration calls it a "crisis" and the media completely eats it up! Yes, the rainy day funds from previous was spent; it was spent to offset tax increases on the already overtaxed homeowners in LB. The Republican Coalition used the "rainy day" fund for the rainy day called the "Great Recession." If the current economic collapse is not a rainy day one has to ask, how excatly does this inept administartion define a rainy day?

Here is the bottom line that is undisputed. At the end of the day, when all the books were closed and the budhet lines were checked and double checked by auditors, there was a $107,000 balance, that is a surplus. In a perfect world, at the end of the day, expenses should balance out with revenues- you should have a $0 balance- that is a perfectly balanced budget. LB had a $107,000 surplus! This shell game the administration is playinng is extremely dangerous, it hurts the repuatation of the city and it scares taxpayers. And the media's feeding into the frenzy is irresponsible.

The facts are the facts. Ask yourself, was there a fund balance at the end of the day or not? Yes there was! I'll take that in these tough economic times.

Reply
Comment_arrow

barry greene

10:40 am on Wednesday, February 8, 2012

Jimmy. I never considered you a moron, but this posting makes you one of two things, really stupid or a total moron. This fund balance that remained...$100k was at the end of June 2011. You should know this, unless you are trying to lie here, or again you are just plain stupid, the City LOST a combined $3.8 million lat year. THIS IS NOT A PERFECTLY BALANCED BUDGET!. They didn't even budget for the interest that they knew they needed to pay on their outstanding bonds!! And this new group is inept? Your buddy Sofield knew there was only $100K left and they gave out raises, promotions and grade changes that cost the City over $700k. Your good ol boys were socking it to this City until december when they gave more of their buddies promotions. They even said that not being able to make payroll happened all the time. Again, you cannot be this stupid Jimmy....at least, on this one, use the Margaret alias to hide it. And BTW, $107K is .1%..that's right, a tenth of a percent of our budget. Normal practice is 5-8%. Moodys always frowned on using fund balances to balance budgets and this is why. Where did all the money go Jimmy? The recession didn't spend it. Where is it Jimmy? Who's got the dough?

Comment_arrow

MikeC.

11:15 am on Wednesday, February 8, 2012

I have to agree with you on this one Jimbo: the facts are the facts. The fact is there is a lot of money that seems to be missing and cannot be accounted for. Where is it? Don't know whether or not heads will roll here, but there seems to be a lot of "no comments" and unanswered phone calls to former officials by the media. A very bright light is going to start shining on LB politics real soon.

Comment_arrow

Tom

11:52 am on Wednesday, February 8, 2012

Dude, I am independent and have no loyalty or connections to either party, so no skin in this political game. But not for nothing, you are freak'n kidding with this post right?

Please tell me your really don't believe what you're saying and just trying to spin for the prior admin.

Comment_arrow

Tom

11:52 am on Wednesday, February 8, 2012

.... Oh and that clicking sound you hear just might be the cuffs closing on some of those who were in power.

Comment_arrow

tired

11:57 am on Wednesday, February 8, 2012

What did you spend the 7.4M on?

Comment_arrow

Margaret

9:02 pm on Wednesday, February 8, 2012

Tom, yes that cracklng sound is the cuffs-- the cuffs on democrat mike fagen indicted on 38 counts of grand larceny

Jimmy Hennessy

9:57 am on Wednesday, February 8, 2012

Lets get one thing straight, does the city have fiscal problems, absolutely- it exists at every level of government. My point is that this administration is blowing the situation completely out of proportion, exaggerating the situation, hurting our real estate values and our ability to borrow money. Its a shell game. It is the clubhouse demcorats attempt to lay the groundwork for a huge tax increase so they can hire more of their family and friends and implement their big government agenda at the local level.

Reply
Comment_arrow

LB TAXPAYA

10:10 am on Wednesday, February 8, 2012

There are several families that employ multiple members in LB. I don't want to name names, cause we all know who they are. They have milked LB for 2 long! Nepotism at it's finest! Alive and strong in the S*itty of Long Beach

Comment_arrow

Tom

11:49 am on Wednesday, February 8, 2012

Please share whatever you're smoking with the rest of the city maybe they'll enjoy the wizard of oz view you have as well.

Comment_arrow

tired

11:59 am on Wednesday, February 8, 2012

Who caused the the fiscal problems you are speaking of? What did you spend the 7.4m surplus on?

Comment_arrow

Jimmy Hennessy

5:14 pm on Wednesday, February 8, 2012

Found this article: 93% of metro cities in 2009 were negatively effected by the recession- but the new city council would have you believe LB was immune! We made it until now without raising taxes and we still ended the last budget year with a surplus! These people are just using scare tactics to raise your taxes so they can hire their friends; just like in 2006! Watch out!

http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/29866657/ns/business-stocks_and_economy/t/few-us-cities-escape-reach-recession/#.TzLuT-OXTEE

R Gregor

10:20 am on Wednesday, February 8, 2012

After reading the past few articles on our fiscal death spiral I come to one conclusion. The same old Long Beach politics. It is pathetic that all of our past and current City Councils both republican and democrat can't get passed bashing each other, trying to make the other look bad in order to make themselves look Better. All the residents of Long Beach will judge the current administration on how well they serve on the City Council and the decisions they make on our behalf. So please everyone just stop the bashing try to be open minded and let's see what this NEW City Council can do for us.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Margaret

9:01 pm on Wednesday, February 8, 2012

What they can do has been made clear- they go against their campaign promises and in their first 4 weeks in office they hired 9 friends and family members with raises... Way to go dems.. oh yea, then dem councilman fagen gets indicted on 38 counts of larceny.. keep up the good work

Ed

10:25 am on Wednesday, February 8, 2012

Mr. Hennessy....the independent audit...hired by republicans...showed massive mis management of funds....lied to the residents...lied to Moodys....its criminal. Stop with your BS. If taxes have to be raised...its because of your cronies who set the stage. simple. In have nothing but respect for you and the work you have done. Stop defending those who did wrong...criminally wrong...just because they are your party. Let the Feds conduct their investigation and let the Dems try to fix LB...you guys certainly didnt.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Margaret

9:02 pm on Wednesday, February 8, 2012

If the republicans in 2004 can take office and face a nearly $7 million dollar deficit and not raise taxes-- why cant the dems inherit a $100k surplus and avoid raising taxes??? Are they just not capable of creating a budget without raising taxes???

laocoon

10:48 am on Wednesday, February 8, 2012

Special agents from the US Attorneys' Office visited a number of City employees' homes this morning asking questions about corruption. This is starting to get very big.

Reply

John Corey

10:50 am on Wednesday, February 8, 2012

Jimmy..Other municipalities like Rockville Centre , Garden City, Lynbrook, have all weathered the same storms yet their bond ratings are triple A plus. The fact is that you and your party pissed away millions and lied to Moody's about it. And along the way you wrecked the pd, fd, and the recreation dept. The Feds are coming.

Reply

MeAgain

12:23 pm on Wednesday, February 8, 2012

its indictment day in Long Beach!

Reply

laocoon

12:36 pm on Wednesday, February 8, 2012

One's indicted this afternoon. There will be more.

Reply

Bobby

2:44 pm on Wednesday, February 8, 2012

Since when is a $100,000 end of the year fund balance a financial crisis?

Something does not ad up at all. Aren't we living in a recession? Shouldn't we be happy we have any money left at the end of the year? This is far better than communities around us. What am I missing here?

-confused or duped by the media and political spin

Reply

Billy Boy

3:44 pm on Wednesday, February 8, 2012

The thing that sticks with me- Long Beach has the honor of being one of 17 municipalities out of 10,000 to get such a huge downgrade by Moodys. Secondly- the auditor spoke about a "bond note" that the city had used- and stated that is something he has only seen twice and the ones who do it have seroius problems. Ladtly and most important- Jim Hennessey the poster child for the old administration is actually trying to defend his old buddies running the city into the ground.
I can only hope that the residents read his blogs and please, please remember them when they come out next year and try to make you think they did a good job.

Reply

Outraged Dem

4:19 pm on Wednesday, February 8, 2012

TWO-FACE BANCHICK!!

Last night a woman went to the city council meeting. She said her name was Ruth Bernstein, but someone said that wasn't her her name-her real name is Ruth Banchick. She obviously a supporter of the new democrat council. She was calling on an FBI investigation of the previous council for mismanaging the city. Its funny though, where is she today? Where has she been since Fagan was arrested for stealing unemployment benefits? Why isn't she calling in the FBI to investigate this criminal? She is curiously very quiet! Funny, I also heard her son Aaron was one of the first people hired by the city manager as well! (What happened to friend and family she fought again- I guess her family is exempt). She is indicative of the two faced hypocrisy that this new administration stands for, and she and the rest of the clubhouse should be screaming bloody murder against how Fagan ripped off our taxpayer money. The Banchicks are an example of all that is wrong in America today!

Reply

John Corey

7:34 pm on Wednesday, February 8, 2012

Jimmy.. The City of Long Beach is self insured. That 8 million was there for that reason,
To pay out insurance claims. You and cronie Scofield blew the money now the Feds are on the way

Reply

Carol Brady

8:10 pm on Wednesday, February 8, 2012

Well if the city gets some money from the hotel....maybe they can go to lunch there!

Reply

Tideline

7:00 am on Thursday, February 9, 2012

The Hotel owes over $457K to the City of LB. A deadbeat of
Major proporations at the worst possible time.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Carol Brady

7:46 am on Thursday, February 9, 2012

Wrong ... The Hotel has paid half of their debt owed to the city. When you go chapter 11 the government allows you to restructure and holds money in escrow for taxes which was done.

Castles Made of Sand

8:53 am on Thursday, February 9, 2012

Jimmy Hennessy - were you sworn in as "Jimmy" as in "I, Jimmy Carter do solemnly swear..."? My first re-election campaign advise, start using James. You sound like a dopey kid that doesn't know math and might lose millions of dollars should you ever get elected. Oh wait, you guys already did that. Secondly, get rid of that "Mr. Happy Guy" picture. Your harsh criticisms make you look two-faced. Third, keep a low profile. As in, don't chime in to patch so many years before running again. You are already coming across like the village idiot on some listener call in show. The truth here folks is that LB has been run by incompetents and crooks for most of it's life. We still elect people who have absolutely no business running a city. We elect firemen and lifeguards and people who failed in finance and politics elsewhere. We even have a school board that are spendthrifts, arrogant, and one doesn't even have a high school diploma. What do we expect the outcome to be? And Jimmy, the link to article on msn.com - really?. We have only a 100k in surplus and we used to have millions. We're not as bad off as Elkhart, Indiana. You win. Everybody dance now

Reply
Comment_arrow

LB4

9:41 am on Thursday, February 9, 2012

Hennessy is being overly defensive to the point that deceit is obvious. Even an amateur lawyer knows to admit fault to the obvious little things in order to make the bigger contentions more believable.

Tideline

9:29 am on Thursday, February 9, 2012

Carol, my information is correct as per a personal visit to city hall tuesday at 3:00. Your saying they paid half thier debt within the last 36 hours ? Possible, but not likley. What is your source of information and when is it current as of ? You failed to say when and how much was alledegly paid. I doubt it.

Reply

laocoon

9:35 am on Thursday, February 9, 2012

The Allegrea is still in arrears on its taxes. Just looked them up. But so are 1,800 other Long Beach property owners. Some for ten years....

Reply

Tideline

9:48 am on Thursday, February 9, 2012

Iaocoom, thanks for that information. Do you have a current outstanding figure ? Then we will know if Carol is correct, or talking out of her third point of contact.

Reply

SeanyA

10:47 am on Thursday, February 9, 2012

I think this city needs to abandon the City Council and go with a mayoral system. Enough is enough.

Reply

Sam Winograd

3:20 pm on Thursday, February 9, 2012

This financial crisis in LB made today's Wall Street Journal - here are some excerpts:

Long Beach: Small City, Big Fiscal Mess

“They systemically over-estimated revenues and under-budgeted expenses,” said Long Beach’s new city manager, Jack Schnirman, a Harvard-educated management consultant and former press aide to U.S. Sen. John Kerry.

To pay its bills, the city in December bailed itself out with a jolt of short-term borrowing, a signal to bond raters that Long Beach’s problems went far deeper than they had realized.

A few days later, Moody’s Investors Service downgraded Long Beach’s $48.3 million general obligation debt to its lowest investment grade, citing the city’s declining mortgage-tax revenues and soaring spending. Long Beach’s rating suffered one of the steepest plunges in the public-finance sphere.

“The position had gotten far worse than we had expected,” said a Moody’s analyst.

Schnirman said he’s going up against a “culture of spending and a lack of accountability.”

Reply

Dick Izinya

3:23 pm on Thursday, February 9, 2012

I hope Dotty doesn't raise prices for those delicious sweet potato fries

Reply

Jimmy Hennessy

2:46 pm on Friday, February 10, 2012

As predicted, the "independent" minded city manager Jack Shnirman hired long time Democrat Clubhouse member, committeeman and operative to work in the city. He has been hired in the Community Development office as a "community liaison." The Community Development office has historically be run with one person only. This hire adds another list to the family and friends broken promise of this "new" administration and it violates a "hiring freeze" that was announced on Tuesday (and enacted by the city council ) with the fiscal emergency resolution. Again, how can there be a "fiscal crisis" and yet the "new" democrats keep hiring there friends??

Reply

Neutron

5:29 pm on Friday, February 10, 2012

Mr. Hennessy, how would you suggest people interpret your posts? You have said in several posts since the election that you hope the new administration and city manager succeed. But then you bash them at every turn while their administration is in its infancy, before they have done much more than try to assess what they have inherited. Many recognize that your singular political view and unwavering party loyalty pushes you to defend the previous administration and to cast doubt on your political rivals currently in office. But…if this is even possible for you…take off your political glasses for a moment and think not as a local party leader, but as an average tax paying citizen of this city. What the citizens of this city want and need is good and efficient government. We want to know that our hard earned dollars that we pay in taxes are being spent wisely and effectively by our elected officials. Like those of us that have to balance our checkbook each month, we want our government to live within their means. Some of us don’t care what party a politician comes from. We put the well-being of the city above a political party. What is your top priority? Rather than working to get your candidates into office at any cost, can you refocus that energy to fixing our city’s problems? Is your party the only path to fixing our problems? Can you put the well-being of the city and its residents above your party?

Reply

Leave a comment