City Council to Vote on Boardwalk Consulting Firm

Ideas begin to materialize for stronger walkway.

Story by Joley Welkowitz and Joseph Kellard.

As residents debate the best way to rebuild the battered Long Beach boardwalk, the City Council will vote Tuesday on a proposed contract with a Syosset-based engineering consulting firm, LiRo Engineers Inc., to prepare plans for its reconstruction.
Follow Long Beach Patch on Facebook.  

City officials on Jan 4 received five bids for engineering consulting services to prepare detailed plans and specifications to rebuild the boardwalk, from design schematics to inspection services, and interviewed three of the proposers, according to the Jan. 22 resolution. LiRo Engineers Inc. is the “most qualified,” having provided its services for projects such as the post-9/11 rebuilding of lower Manhattan and the Roosevelt Island Tramway, the resolution states.  

A legislative memo accompanying the item notes that LiRo Engineers Inc., “will be responsible for the researching and presenting of the best practice options for the design and materials of the boardwalk, as well as overseeing the eventual construction process, including the solicitation of public input and assisting in the advertisement of the bid and oversight of the bid process in advance of the management of the construction of the new boardwalk.”

The cost of the contract is $565,307, and the city will request funding through grant monies from the Federal Emergency Management Agency, the resolution states.  

Meanwhile, building a new boardwalk has become a hot topic of debate among residents, as work crews demolish the boardwalk, a project that officially started following a ceremony commemorating the iconic wooden walkway at Grand Boulevard on Jan. 5.

One resident in attendance, Steve Furair, told Patch that he believes the new structure needs to consist of different materials. “As much as I want a wooden boardwalk, concrete would be the safest and may make the most sense,” he said.

But there are residents such as Noreen Duffy, who is adamant that the city stick with a wooden boardwalk. “It’s the ocean, it’s the beach, and wood comes from the earth and it goes with the whole thing,” she said.

Be a Follower. Explore and subscribe to Patch groups.

One option used on boardwalks along the East Coast is Ipe (pronounced EE-pay), a wood harvested from the Amazon. Ipe is deemed more durable than wood found in the United States, but controversy surrounds its use.

According to environmental groups, the wood in the Amazon has not been replaced as fast as it has been cut down, and organizations such as Rainforest Relief have put pressure on municipalities to stop its use in areas such as Coney Island.

Matthew Chartrand, president of Ironworkers Local 361, presented another alternative to wood at the City Council meeting on Jan 8. Chartrand proposed that structural precast concrete — a mix of concrete and rebar (steel reinforced bars) — is the answer to Long Beach’s dilemma.

“The top is grooved to look like wood with epoxy paint, so it is more pleasing to the eye,” Chartrand said.  

Ironworkers Local 361 repaired sections of the Coney Island boardwalk between 2010 and 2012 with the proposed concrete and replaced sections that survived the October storm, Chartrand told the council. Structural precast concrete also gives more than regular concrete and the epoxy paint gives it some elasticity, so structural precast is easier to walk on, he continued.

“A plus of structural precast is that it is relatively maintenance free,“ Chartrand said.

The concrete needs maintenance about every 10 years, compared to wood, which usually needs maintenance much sooner, sometimes after one year. The weight of the proposed concrete boardwalk alone keeps it held down better than wood and therefore does not need any type of barrier, he said.

“You want to build a boardwalk to withstand the biggest storm that could possibly come in 100 years,” he said. “I think structural precast concrete can do that.”

RhondaVW January 22, 2013 at 03:59 PM
A concrete / composite substructure that could be retrofitted over LB's existing pilings and allow for the use of wood, plastic, concrete, or any combination of decking options. http://tinyurl.com/HCB-Boardwalk http://tinyurl.com/LBNY-HCB
RhondaVW January 22, 2013 at 04:02 PM
A chemical-free, made in the USA decking wood that is exempt from EPA regulation, Class A Fire Rated, and 50% stronger than CCA or ACQ treated lumber. http://tinyurl.com/TimberSILPDF
paul.d.spellman January 22, 2013 at 04:10 PM
Yes but will they survive the next vicious storm inflicted upon us?
RhondaVW January 22, 2013 at 04:17 PM
Yes. just like Long Beache's sturdy concrete substructure did. You can watch some of the testing here: http://tinyurl.com/HCB-Videos
LB Swimmer January 22, 2013 at 04:24 PM
Anything but wood! Look for a longer term, lower maintenance fix that doesn't rattle your teeth when you ride a bike on it.
paul.d.spellman January 22, 2013 at 04:29 PM
Testing? Has this been applied in the field? Has any govt locale actually used this stuff? What is to say the next sandy storm wont tear this off and leave us with an even more expensive pile of material we can no longer use?
RhondaVW January 22, 2013 at 04:47 PM
Hi Paul, Yes. it has been applied. IL, ME, MO, NJ, CO, I believe I read there is a bridge going up in UT or NM I forget which. I think the US military is working on a bridge with the beams as well. http://tinyurl.com/HCBSpans As Mr. Eddie posted on elsewhere, LB's boardwalk wasn't torn off it floated off because it wasn't adequately secured to the piling cap beams.
CM January 23, 2013 at 10:41 AM
Don't we have to know what dunes or other protective barrier will be in place before the boardwalk design is decided? The City Council chose not to build the dunes in the past, in part, because they would block the view from the boardwalk. I want some protection in place against future stiorms first and then a boardwalk.
LB Swimmer January 23, 2013 at 01:06 PM
Is there any relationship between the plans to rebuild the boardwalk and the flood control studies performed in the past? Is the council putting the cart before the horse?
Trying to Make Sense January 24, 2013 at 10:33 AM
Quite (quiet) a stream of holy(holly) consciousness you put out there EZ. Thanks for sharing(just my opinion).


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something